
An Arizona man now faces a terrorism charge after prosecutors say he described bombing two houses of worship and having an accomplice shoot survivors as they ran for safety.
Quick Take
- Maricopa County prosecutors charged Matthew Bjornholt with making a terroristic threat tied to an alleged plot against Jewish or Muslim worship sites.
- Court papers say he described one bomb as a decoy to draw people toward a second blast, with a gunman “picking off” those who fled.
- A home search turned up three guns and a copy of The Anarchist Cookbook, which prosecutors say he called his “Bible.”
- His defense attorney calls the whole case hearsay, says the FBI reviewed his phones and found nothing, and notes no bomb materials were found.
What Prosecutors Say Bjornholt Planned
Court documents describe a two-stage attack. One bomb would go off at a place of worship to draw a crowd outside. A second, larger bomb would then hit a nearby site. An accomplice would wait and shoot people as they escaped the blasts. Prosecutors say Bjornholt told a witness that after the bombs went off, his partner would start “picking off people.” The alleged targets were Jewish or Muslim institutions, though the exact locations in Maricopa County have not been made public.
Investigators searched Bjornholt’s home and reported finding three firearms along with a copy of The Anarchist Cookbook, a text long associated with homemade explosives and tied to the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing. Prosecutors told the court he referred to the book as his “Bible.” That detail, more than any single piece of evidence, is what pushed this case into national headlines.
The Court’s Ruling and the Bond Conditions
A judge found enough evidence to let the case move forward and set a $100,000 secured bond. Conditions include electronic monitoring, a ban on owning weapons, and no contact with witnesses or alleged victims. That ruling means a judge found probable cause to proceed, not that guilt has been proven. The single filed charge is one count of making a terroristic threat, not conspiracy, attempted bombing, or a weapons-of-mass-destruction offense.
The Council on American-Islamic Relations’ Arizona chapter publicly welcomed the state charge and pressed federal prosecutors to bring similar charges of their own, framing the allegations as a thwarted mass-casualty plot. That kind of public pressure is understandable given the subject matter. Still, it also shows how quickly an unproven allegation can harden into a settled narrative before a jury ever hears the evidence.
The Defense Says the Case Rests on One Man’s Word
Bjornholt’s attorney, Chad Shell, says the entire case comes from a former acquaintance Bjornholt had recently kicked out of his house, and that the man’s account was never corroborated. Shell told reporters the statements were “all made up.” He also says federal agents searched Bjornholt’s phones and computers with his consent and found nothing connected to terrorism, after which the FBI closed its file without charges.
Shell further argues that no bomb-making materials turned up during the home search, and that the three firearms were legally owned with only enough ammunition to fill standard magazines. He says federal investigators reached the same conclusion before Maricopa County decided to pursue its own charges. That gap between what the FBI and county prosecutors decided matters. It raises a fair question: did state prosecutors see something federal agents missed, or did they reach a different judgment call on the same thin evidence?
Why Cases Like This One Keep Showing Up in Court
This case fits a pattern that has defined American counterterrorism since the September 11 attacks. Federal prosecutors have leaned harder into stopping alleged plots before they happen rather than waiting for an attack. One academic review of 574 federal terrorism indictments found the share built around prevented, rather than completed, acts jumped from 29 percent before 9/11 to 60 percent in the years after. That shift can save lives. It can also mean prosecutors sometimes build cases on thinner evidence, chasing words instead of actions.
Houses of worship remain rare but real targets for violence, which is exactly why allegations like this one trigger such intense public reaction. But rare targets and serious allegations demand serious proof, not just an alarming quote from a disgruntled former roommate. Arizona’s courts will now have to sort out whether this was a credible plot in the making or a falling-out between two men that spiraled into a criminal case built on one person’s word against another’s.
For now, Bjornholt sits under house arrest and electronic monitoring while his case moves through Maricopa County Superior Court. The next hearings will test whether prosecutors can produce anything beyond the witness statement that started it all.
Sources:
nypost.com, azfamily.com, azcentral.com, tucson.com, yahoo.com








